Tribunal discussion/views/debate

[The Sleeping Giant]

Birss got the same as Delvins.

[Brodlach]

Looks like someone has plead innocent broadlach. Morris?

Looking at the vision, he might be in a bit of trouble too

[Brodlach]

Birss gets 1 too

Reckless - Low - High Contact

250 Points

-45% Good Record & Guilty Plea

137.5 Points

1 Match

Thats alot of points for being reckless and low impact

[The Sleeping Giant]

High Contact is the killer I think.

[Blacky]

Ben Macreadie found guilty
intentional-low- high contact
225 points
-20% guity plea
180 total points
1 Match
i dont belive it one game
you little ripper

[Mark_Beswick]

Looking ahead - Andy will be pulling his hair out

Cassisi likely Power out - S. Ezard In?
MacReadie Out (Susp)- Motlop In?
N. Caruso (Inj) - Rankine In?
Birss Out (Susp) - Anderson In?
Moran ?(Crows)? - Fisher In
Schmidt ?(Crows) - Hankin to Debut?
Davenport - ? Bricknell
Morris - Blessing

Webb In?
Sturt would be licking their lips with up to 7 possible changes to last weeks winning side...
You could just see the Power or Crows taking emergencies this week... Unley Oval may continue to haunt us - Hopefully we can rise to the challenege ahead

[Brodlach]

Crap...Steve Morris 3 matches

Intentional - Medium - Body Contact

325 Points

No Deductions

3 Matches

[Brodlach]

Thought he was in trouble but three matches is way over the top

[Mark_Beswick]

Have to appeal that! Maybe he should change his name to Gowans by deed poll

[The Sleeping Giant]

Your kidding? Don't agree with that one.

[Mark_Beswick]

Maybe some money is on sturt this week to pay some power debts

[blood bath]

What a load of bulls&!t.

Not worth 3, maybe 1. Macreadie as good as king hits someone and gets 1 and Morris gets 3. Joke

[bloods08]

Crap...Steve Morris 3 matches

Intentional - Medium - Body Contact

325 Points

No Deductions

3 Matches

Extremely unlucky. See 2 or 3 of those a game and they only get a free kick. Probably got lucky with Macreadie so probably evens itself out in the end. Morris will be hard to replace though.

[Mark_Beswick]

That equates to 4 weeks suspension as after he serves three, he has the bye

[blood bath]

Who did Morris hit? Was there substantial injury that may have contributed to the hefty suspension?

[Brodlach]

Who did Morris hit? Was there substantial injury that may have contributed to the hefty suspension?

It was very late

Watch it on here

http://video.adelaidenow.com.au/2000283 ... und-Eleven

[Brodlach]

Andy Collins will be furious at these three lads I reckon

[Peter Griffen]

Macreadie should have got 3, Birss is correct with 1 and Morris a reprimand at most! I am speechless!

[Mark_Beswick]

Pleaded Guilty - thus must be intentional - no deduction

Body contact (Not high) - I think an appeal is in order. Maybe a differentl panel and maybe someone who has some football feel with a fresh appeal.

Maybe Westies should hire the CDFC to help with the appeal or someone from NFC. All their players have got off this year -

You could bet if it was an AFL listed player, the penalties would have been different - maybe walkered out without penalty even

[blood bath]

Have to appeal that! Maybe he should change his name to Gowans by deed poll

Gowans only got 3 for his king hit on Schubert in the 07 GF. Morris get 3 for a fractionally late hip and shoulder. Again, any danger of consistency