Page 9 of 10
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Tue Jun 27, 2017 4:13 pmby Mickyj
Spargo wrote:Mickyj wrote:Glenelg must have sound issues the guy on the mic was just garbled Crap
As opposed to posting it...
Better than sounding like a bad loser Glenelg fan
Mock me all you like
Couldn't care less loser like your team
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Tue Jun 27, 2017 4:49 pmby am Bays
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Tue Jun 27, 2017 7:34 pmby goddy11
Can't believe this one
Glenelg midfielder Matt Snook will challenge a three-match ban for striking Eagle Jake Comitogianni at Gliderol Stadium on Saturday.
Matt Snook (Glenelg) – Striking
Conduct: Intentional
Impact: Medium
Contact: High
Penalty: 3 Matches (Base Sanction)
Early Plea: 2 Matches
About 40 seconds into the video
https://youtu.be/0LxLtsrIqW4He's gone
The L Hender one was a sling tackle. Just don't understand how he just received a fine.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Tue Jun 27, 2017 7:44 pmby GMcG
Spargo wrote:If we lose to Centrals this week you can almost rule a line through us.
We will win by 5 goals.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Tue Jun 27, 2017 8:35 pmby am Bays
goddy11 wrote:Can't believe this one
Glenelg midfielder Matt Snook will challenge a three-match ban for striking Eagle Jake Comitogianni at Gliderol Stadium on Saturday.
Matt Snook (Glenelg) – Striking
Conduct: Intentional
Impact: Medium
Contact: High
Penalty: 3 Matches (Base Sanction)
Early Plea: 2 Matches
About 40 seconds into the video
https://youtu.be/0LxLtsrIqW4He's gone
The L Hender one was a sling tackle. Just don't understand how he just received a fine.
Penalty allegedly reduced to 1 match/reprimand (guilty plea). He's taken the rap, free to play Sat.
Finally we get looked after by the tribunal after last years Joshy Woodall travesty.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 11:30 amby goddy11
am Bays wrote:goddy11 wrote:Can't believe this one
Glenelg midfielder Matt Snook will challenge a three-match ban for striking Eagle Jake Comitogianni at Gliderol Stadium on Saturday.
Matt Snook (Glenelg) – Striking
Conduct: Intentional
Impact: Medium
Contact: High
Penalty: 3 Matches (Base Sanction)
Early Plea: 2 Matches
About 40 seconds into the video
https://youtu.be/0LxLtsrIqW4He's gone
The L Hender one was a sling tackle. Just don't understand how he just received a fine.
Penalty allegedly reduced to 1 match/reprimand (guilty plea). He's taken the rap, free to play Sat.
Finally we get looked after by the tribunal after last years Joshy Woodall travesty.
How does that work? Gets 3 matches/ 2 if he accepts guilty, appeals and gets 1 match or reprimand if guilty plea. He has to be guilty, just look at the video. These tribunals are crazy. His appeal must suggest he thinks he is innocent so if he now accepts a guilty plea , does this mean the tribunal is asking him to lie so he can get a reprimand.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 12:23 pmby another grub
Yes. Complete farce. The whole league
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 1:33 pmby human_torpedo
After viewing the incident he got off very lightly to be able to play this week. Hard to gauge force from the video, but intent was certainly there. 2 weeks down to 1 would have been fair IMO
How do you get an early plea option after an appeal? isn't the early plea option taken away via the appeal?
The comp becomes more laughable by the day
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 2:55 pmby goddy11
human_torpedo wrote:After viewing the incident he got off very lightly to be able to play this week. Hard to gauge force from the video, but intent was certainly there. 2 weeks down to 1 would have been fair IMO
How do you get an early plea option after an appeal? isn't the early plea option taken away via the appeal?
The comp becomes more laughable by the day
HT. You mirror my thoughts. Triple Jeopardy decision for the player. Looks like head high punches OK. I can not find if this is official on SANFL website to confirm but if he received no fine, how does the North guy feel having to fork out a $200 fine for rough play. He may have done a Bachar Houli thing and brought all his mates and people that live nearby in as character witnesses.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 3:24 pmby matt35
From SANFL Twitter:
NFLVerified account @SANFL · 19h19 hours ago
More
Matt Snook @GlenelgFC penalty classification reduced to 1 mtch ban (Fine & Rep w early plea). Pleaded guilty to striking. Free to play Sat.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 3:26 pmby matt35
So my take from that is that because the classification of the incident was changed, Snook was given the chance to pleed guilty to the lower category of incident.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 3:58 pmby human_torpedo
matt35 wrote:So my take from that is that because the classification of the incident was changed, Snook was given the chance to pleed guilty to the lower category of incident.
By appealing the classification change, wouldn't he be essentially saying 'yes I hit him, but a lower classification' so he is pleading guilty anyway?
I am just surprised that the appeal didn't lead to a reduction to a 1 match suspension on the basis of a lower classification. The fact he is free to play this week after that incident astounds me
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 6:54 pmby goddy11
I wonder if the SANFL has the same balls as the AFL to say the penalty is manifestly not sufficient.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 9:17 pmby am Bays
Maybe the SANFL has the guilts towards us given how you mob squealed when Boyd tripped over his own feet in the 2nd last game last year and you whinged to the SANFL and poor Joshy Woodall got four games.
The ride you mob get for doing the SANFL a favour in 1990 surely has to end soon
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Wed Jun 28, 2017 11:05 pmby saintal
Just watched it for the first time, deserved at least a couple. Very lucky.
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Thu Jun 29, 2017 9:06 pmby daysofourlives
Is this round finished yet or does it have another week or so to go?
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Thu Jun 29, 2017 9:12 pmby Brodlach
I'm happy for this round to carry on right through to next season
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Thu Jun 29, 2017 9:14 pmby Dutchy
No teams on SANFL site, maybe we have gone into recess!!!
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Thu Jun 29, 2017 10:17 pmby Big Phil
Re: Round 10
Posted:
Thu Jun 29, 2017 10:22 pmby Dutchy
