Page 8 of 18
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:00 pmby Hazydog
. “You take out 5 of your listed players today and replace them with kids or country league jobbers”
Which then compromises the comp in a different manner...
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:01 pmby LMA
MW wrote:Higher salary means higher output? Please
As usual this is only an issue when they are winning
And when they are not winning they're not trying.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:07 pmby JK
am Bays wrote:Good Game of footy we had our chances but didn’t capitalise on them
No excuse, next game is our focus
Season long way from finished for your boys mate, lost no admirers today
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:10 pmby Wedgie
Im with MW, there's no reason Adelaide United would get beaten by Manchester City. Salary is irrelevent.
There's obviously not an IQ test to become a Crows or West supporter.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:11 pmby LMA
daysofourlives wrote:LMA wrote:Jim05 wrote:LMA wrote:Just last week on here both Port and Adelaide were accused of not trying and not wanting to win. FFS stick to one view, are they trying or are they too good.
Glenelg are still the best side by far, our Ammo boys stood up today though.
I’ve always maintained they are too good and wouldn’t care if they were forced to field a team that was beaten by 10 goals every week. They absolutely should not ever be allowed to win a flag
If Port or Adelaide can win a flag than AFL listed players is the least of the SANFL problems. They need to cap the amount payments true amateur footballers are getting to keep quality players at SANFL level. SANFL clubs also need to stop paying reserve players and reward higher payments for the league players. This will ensure that Port or Adelaide will never win a flag, not capping the amount of SANFL standard AFL players playing SANFL.
Nope the SANFL needs to lift the salary cap and if the clubs cant afford it the AFL should subsidise it. Basically double it to about 700k, and increase of about 300k or 2.4m per year. chicken feed for the AFL to ensure their franchises keep getting talent through the doors.
Either that or I like Cennals idea
, all 8 clubs just agree to play their league side in the reserves and vice versa
Good way of flushing $50k a year from the league down the toilet. Knowing that Centrals and South voted no are they accepting the money from the SANFL?
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:17 pmby LMA
Wedgie wrote:Im with MW, there's no reason Adelaide United would get beaten by Manchester City. Salary is irrelevent.
There's obviously not an IQ test to become a Crows or West supporter.
It is in a country where it's your number one sport compared to a country where its fourth in the pecking order. Man City's B grade of course?
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Sun Sep 08, 2019 11:18 pmby Dutchy
MW wrote:Higher salary means higher output? Please
As usual this is only an issue when they are winning
No, the comp is terrible when they are poor also (Crows last year).
The issue is their SANFL output is purely determined via their injury list
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 12:43 amby StrayDog
LMA wrote:daysofourlives wrote:LMA wrote:Jim05 wrote:I’ve always maintained they are too good and wouldn’t care if they were forced to field a team that was beaten by 10 goals every week. They absolutely should not ever be allowed to win a flag
If Port or Adelaide can win a flag than AFL listed players is the least of the SANFL problems. They need to cap the amount payments true amateur footballers are getting to keep quality players at SANFL level. SANFL clubs also need to stop paying reserve players and reward higher payments for the league players. This will ensure that Port or Adelaide will never win a flag, not capping the amount of SANFL standard AFL players playing SANFL.
Nope the SANFL needs to lift the salary cap and if the clubs cant afford it the AFL should subsidise it. Basically double it to about 700k, and increase of about 300k or 2.4m per year. chicken feed for the AFL to ensure their franchises keep getting talent through the doors.
Either that or I like Cennals idea
, all 8 clubs just agree to play their league side in the reserves and vice versa
Good way of flushing $50k a year from the league down the toilet.
Knowing that Centrals and South voted no are they accepting the money from the SANFL?
Why shouldn't they?
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 12:50 amby therisingblues
I dunno Stray dog.
Those 2 are capable of posting decent stuff, but when we get to THIS particular issue, common sense and an ability to keep track of a conversation go flying out the window.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 12:53 amby StrayDog
therisingblues wrote:I dunno Stray dog.
Those 2 are capable of posting decent stuff, but when we get to THIS particular issue, common sense and an ability to keep track of a conversation go flying out the window.
Yeah, sorry about that. It's just that I've always found the alluded point an interesting one.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 3:30 amby Alex
The magpies are the original PAFC. The power are a 1990s creation that has chosen to appropriate undeserved history in recent years for commercial reasons. It's a very convenient story to swallow to make everything fit neatly to suppose that one has always been the other.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 7:59 amby Booney
Morning all.
Going well then?
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 8:45 amby gazzamagoo
Booney wrote:Morning all.
Going well then?
PERSETAN
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 8:48 amby whufc
Booney wrote:Morning all.
Going well then?
Going very well, Well Played. Good luck in the GF.
Yours truly,
Fan who wants to see an all AFL reserves GF as it may be the only way to send a rocket up the fans of the other clubs and start some real action happening.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 8:51 amby whybother
With 2 afl reserve teams playing, and a combined membership of 100000+, a crowd of about 11000 seems a bit poor
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 8:52 amby Booney
gazzamagoo wrote:Booney wrote:Morning all.
Going well then?
PERSETAN
You too.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 8:53 amby Booney
whybother wrote:With 2 afl reserve teams playing, and a combined membership of 100000+, a crowd of about 11000 seems a bit poor
About 15 of the 40 or so people in the Adelaide cheer squad got changed between games into their Glenelg jackets so the numbers are a little skewed.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 9:09 amby Jim05
Booney wrote:Morning all.
Going well then?
All good, if anything the outlook looks a lot brighter as this might just hasten the exit of the two sides from the comp.
Better get your Chinese contacts to start printing out those T-Shirts now
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 9:18 amby Booney
Wedgie wrote:There's obviously not an IQ test to become a Crows or West supporter.
...or North or Sturt or St Kilda or Port or Geelong or Collingwood or West Coast or Gaza or Lockleys.
Thank you, captain obvious.
Re: 2019 2nd Semi Final - Glenelg v Powerserves
Posted:
Mon Sep 09, 2019 9:53 amby woodublieve12
Congratulations to the Power for making the Grand Final
Can they were their clubs proper jumper in the GF???