2012 Reports & Tribunal Discussion

[dedja]

Can't believe the eagles haven't challenged the Rowntree suspension. One of the worst reports I'd ever seen. Should've been thrown out monday morning.

This ... and Willets should have been reported for deliberately head butting his guts.

[Dutchy]

After the Incident Review Panel offered a 1 match ban for 'Rough Conduct' against Justin Hardy, the club has challeneged the decision at the SANFL tribunal this evening. Hardy has been found NOT GUILTY and will be free to play on Saturday against West Adelaide.

[smac]

Again? That's twice in 3 hours that's happened.

[Grahaml]

They must really not like Hardy to report him again.

[CENTURION]

Have you seen the size of Him? I think if He belted someone, they would be dead.

[Pseudo]

Again? That's twice in 3 hours that's happened.

Centurion banned again?

[CENTURION]

Again? That's twice in 3 hours that's happened.

Centurion banned again?

NUP, i'M A GOOD BOY NOW.

[FlyingHigh]

Can't believe the eagles haven't challenged the Rowntree suspension. One of the worst reports I'd ever seen. Should've been thrown out monday morning.

Didn't even think of checking this thread or AdelaideNow for any results because thought the report would have been withdrawn.
Regardless of it being an Eagles player, this is just a complete disgrace.

[CENTURION]

Can't believe the eagles haven't challenged the Rowntree suspension. One of the worst reports I'd ever seen. Should've been thrown out monday morning.

This ... and Willets should have been reported for deliberately head butting his guts.

how can someone headbutt their guts? They must be extremely flexible!

[Wedgie]

James Bennett got a reprimand and Brett Backwell got 2 days.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Lol

[Wedgie]

James Bennett got a reprimand and Brett Backwell got 2 days.

Whoops. That was unintended, stupid flu.
2 WEEKS!

[Grahaml]

I just presumed it was a very clever way of saying he would be found not guilty during the week. Lol.

[The Sleeping Giant]

I know bloke's have been successful this year with appeals, but Backwell ain't getting that one reduced.

[robranisgod]

I know bloke's have been successful this year with appeals, but Backwell ain't getting that one reduced.

He has pleaded guilty so he won't be appealing. Bennett pleaded guilty too. I felt sorry for him in that it was a classic case of the retaliator getting caught and it looked a very minor misdemeanour. I guess a reprimand is a fair result all things considered.

[Mark_Beswick]

Backwell - Says on SANFL site accepted a reprimand from Incident Review panel but 275 pts does equate to 2 games - So which one is it?

[Big Phil]

There are a couple of typos in there so I wouln't be too sure with what is written. I'd suspect Backwell would have taken the 2 week suspension (would have been 3 if not for an early guilty plea) but the person updating the site hasn't put this down correctly.

Interesting to see that Norwood's Matt Suckling had been cited for Umpire Abuse. SANFL twitter feed says he has been given a reprimand.

[robranisgod]

How did Brady Dawe get on. Given that Gallman got 4 broken ribs from the incident if it was the AFL Dawe would be in huge strife.

[Squawk]

How did Brady Dawe get on. Given that Gallman got 4 broken ribs from the incident if it was the AFL Dawe would be in huge strife.

Liam Jurrah hasn't been suspended yet. The AFL cant be that strict.

[Big Phil]

How did Brady Dawe get on. Given that Gallman got 4 broken ribs from the incident if it was the AFL Dawe would be in huge strife.

He was up against the charge of 'misconduct - kneeing'

Brady Dawe has been found Not Guilty by the SANFL Tribunal