Andy Collins

[The Sleeping Giant]

i dont think he should go, gotta give him a fair crack, if no finals next year, then questions to be asked. he has improved the wins each year so far.

I would say 4 years is a decent crack at it.

[Brodlach]

i dont think he should go, gotta give him a fair crack, if no finals next year, then questions to be asked. he has improved the wins each year so far.

I would say 4 years is a decent crack at it.

I certainly dont think the first 2-3 count as had had absolutely nothing to begin with. No players, money or heart. This is the first year he has had some decent players but injury really has derailed the season. At least 10 first choice players missed on the weekend, not including Schmidt who most thought he would play all year for us.

[whufc]

i dont think he should go, gotta give him a fair crack, if no finals next year, then questions to be asked. he has improved the wins each year so far.

I would say 4 years is a decent crack at it.

I certainly dont think the first 2-3 count as had had absolutely nothing to begin with. No players, money or heart. This is the first year he has had some decent players but injury really has derailed the season. At least 10 first choice players missed on the weekend, not including Schmidt who most thought he would play all year for us.

Is it really a surprise West have so many on the injured list especially when you look at some of the players they brought in Fisher and Hartlett who have a history of spending more time in the medical room than on the field.

[Jim05]

A game away from the double chance and people calling for his head

[Brodlach]

i dont think he should go, gotta give him a fair crack, if no finals next year, then questions to be asked. he has improved the wins each year so far.

I would say 4 years is a decent crack at it.

I certainly dont think the first 2-3 count as had had absolutely nothing to begin with. No players, money or heart. This is the first year he has had some decent players but injury really has derailed the season. At least 10 first choice players missed on the weekend, not including Schmidt who most thought he would play all year for us.

Is it really a surprise West have so many on the injured list especially when you look at some of the players they brought in Fisher and Hartlett who have a history of spending more time in the medical room than on the field.

How many times are you going to bring this up this year FFS? How many times do you have to been told about this. Fishers injury had nothing to do with any injury he has had before. The ankle injury he sustained was due to an accident against South running for the ball and the South player stood on his foot. Remeber that there was also many, many other clubs chasing his signature including almost all the SANFL clubs. Hartlett, like his brother, does have injury problems. He has played 5 games in the past two seasons and he wasnt a recruit, has was a player delisted from the AFL returning back to his former club at a time when were really needed experinced players. Had we payed the money that Tiller wanted with his record of injuries then you would be entitled to bring this up for the 500 time this year but the club didnt want to go down that track.

[Brodlach]

A game away from the double chance and people calling for his head

Agreed Jim, but our form has been terrible and if you go through this thread, it isnt West supporters calling for his head its South , Sturt ,Glenelg , and Centrals.

[whufc]

Even Westies supporters are bringing it up on the bloodntars website, im obviously not the only one with this opinion.

[CENTURION]

Even Westies supporters are bringing it up on the bloodntars website, im obviously not the only one with this opinion.

tut tut, trolling about opposition websites...

[Brodlach]

Even Westies supporters are bringing it up on the bloodntars website, im obviously not the only one with this opinion.

tut tut, trolling about opposition websites...

Where are these quotes? I couldnt find any/

[nickname]

[quote="whufc"

Is it really a surprise West have so many on the injured list especially when you look at some of the players they brought in Fisher and Hartlett who have a history of spending more time in the medical room than on the field.[/quote]

Out of our current injury list Hartlett is the only one you could call injury prone. One player. It's a shame for you that the facts don't support this line you keep tediously running.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Should clear up the fact that if West do play finals this year, then Collins should remain. If they don't, well.......

[whufc]

Even Westies supporters are bringing it up on the bloodntars website, im obviously not the only one with this opinion.

tut tut, trolling about opposition websites...

Where are these quotes? I couldnt find any/

http://www.safooty.net/bloodntars/viewt ... f=1&t=2561

[whufc]

Should clear up the fact that if West do play finals this year, then Collins should remain. If they don't, well.......

x2

[Brodlach]

Even Westies supporters are bringing it up on the bloodntars website, im obviously not the only one with this opinion.

tut tut, trolling about opposition websites...

Where are these quotes? I couldnt find any/

http://www.safooty.net/bloodntars/viewt ... f=1&t=2561

Thats ONE quote from ONE person and if you read the rest of his posts on other subjects he does get a little concerned about everything.

[Blacky]

one thing we wont do is sack our coach
we will leave that to the bays

[The Sleeping Giant]

one thing we wont do is sack our coach
we will leave that to the bays

Oh please.

[SANFLnut]

one thing we wont do is sack our coach
we will leave that to the bays

Why would we let the bays sack Collins?

[am Bays]

one thing we wont do is sack our coach
we will leave that to the bays

Rubbers is now free, looking for work in footy and he is one of your favourite sons...

Three and a haf years into his tenure with a "basket case" he had his team sitting top after just playing in the last two final series??

How does that compare to Collins?

[HOORAY PUNT]

Collins is safe I think and in fairness West have copped a lot of injuries and will bounce back shortly.I don't subscribe to the theory of his first 2-3 years didn't count though ,that is his job to immprove the side ...........from day 1 not from year 4.

[Blacky]

one thing we wont do is sack our coach
we will leave that to the bays

Oh please.

bugger the dwarf has spoken again