RD7 Eagles v North Post Match Review

[The Sleeping Giant]

Shagged about this?

Maybe Whyman got a reduced sentence because he was provoked?

[klaan]

Shagged about this?

Maybe Whyman got a reduced sentence because he was provoked?

Provoked by who? Allmond? That's like saying that Mickyj is provoked into posting on this site Doesn't wash with me and it shouldn't happen!!!!!

[The Sleeping Giant]

Just putting up a reason why he may not have been suspended.

[Columbo]

agreed about the sniper, should have got atleast 5.

I've said previously that I didn't see the incident but .... taking into consideration only 4 league players have been suspended for 3 or more weeks since 2004....5 might be pushing it a bit. Is McIntyre good to go this week?

[goraw]

agreed about the sniper, should have got atleast 5.

I've said previously that I didn't see the incident but .... taking into consideration only 4 league players have been suspended for 3 or more weeks since 2004....5 might be pushing it a bit. Is McIntyre good to go this week?

he didnt get to play a half of footy because of the snipers cheap weak as piss punch.maccas recovery has nothing to do with what snipers punishment should be.5 would have been the right decision IMO.

[G]

Surely you dont believe a punch in the guts [no matter how cheap a shot it was] deserves 5 games
I would say 2 games unless you have an ordinary record which would bring it up to 3.

And yes as you can see Im a North man, and saw the incident.

[on the rails]

Surely you dont believe a punch in the guts [no matter how cheap a shot it was] deserves 5 games
I would say 2 games unless you have an ordinary record which would bring it up to 3.

And yes as you can see Im a North man, and saw the incident.

I agree with you G - I thought 1 or 2 at best - 3 plus if he had injured Macca to the point of Macca missing that many games himself.