RD21 Eagles v West Post Game Review

[wycbloods]

Well if he is going to post something that turned out to be so far off the mark (which is was regardless of how you intepret it being worded) then he has to expect comment but he was the one who took the first cheap shot so I replied in kind.

Oh how mature of you .

I am sure you have never posted anything that is way off the mark.

I said he was wrong with the way he worded it. He said very experienced side, something i disagree with, but some would say a reserves side boasting 12 players who have played league footy and 3 premiership players would be an experienced side and i am sure some wouldn't.

His so called cheap shot i would have thought was pointing out to Redden Whites that the person having a go at Williams was not at the game and obviously ill-informed. A reasonable thing to do i would say.

[drebin]

Well if it makes you happy I removed my 2nd post - hate to be accused of taking a cheap shot unlike R&B who can take no criticism when he was wrong but fires back about me venting???

[bosvit]

I thought r&b was obviously having a go at prowling panther but also pointing out to redden whites that prowling panthers post was the only one that even mentioned Super Dick.

Anyway I heard that cans of 'Man Up Princess' are going cheap at Cunninghams Warehouse.

If a few of you grab some the rest of us won't need to listen to this personal attack and whining dribble

[drebin]

Seriously I really hope West beat North this week and then the Bays and that they make the 5 for a bit of success! It might make some of you lot unwind a bit!

[holden78]

Now theres a product just for you Mickyj , you and CD can buy all they have at Cunninghams and hand it around at half time with your donuts

I thought r&b was obviously having a go at prowling panther but also pointing out to redden whites that prowling panthers post was the only one that even mentioned Super Dick.

Anyway I heard that cans of 'Man Up Princess' are going cheap at Cunninghams Warehouse.

If a few of you grab some the rest of us won't need to listen to this personal attack and whining dribble

[Mickyj]

I don't agree with "redandblack" that the Eagles had a very experienced reserves team today. Treeby, Powell and P. Fiacchi were the only established league players in the Team. Would have been at least 12 teenagers in the team.

R&B using the words very experienced was mis-guided. More experienced was probably the correct term.

F Fitzgerald Heinjus Fairclough
HF Rowntree Staple Graham
C Sumner Powell Batley
HB McMahon Hill? P Fiacchi
B Edwards McEntee Papps
Ruck Redden Banner Hicks
Int D Polec Culley Brusnahan
Appleton Treeby

3 league premiership players. approx 12 players who have played league football.

FF Jennings Westhoff Silverlock
HF Langford Knial Luders
C Ward Rowe Keough
HB Laurie Fisher Birss
FB Boundy Brown Scott

1st Ruck Heintz Sukkel Shearer

I/C Ribbons ANderson

This side has 7 players who have played league footy.

To me that is a Eagles side with more experience, even if that experience may not be huge. So is R&B still wrong about the eagles having a more experienced side in the magoo's Drebin?

Also having a crack at R&B for taking a cheap shot that is just laughable coming from you Drebin.

Now lest look at the under 18 players that I know of in the eagles seconds
Heinjus
rowntree
sumner
Polec
Culley
Brusanhan
Redden yep on an afl list and is 18
Not sure if I missed anyone
Hill is 19 so he misses out .

[Mickyj]

Now theres a product just for you Mickyj , you and CD can buy all they have at Cunninghams and hand it around at half time with your donuts

I thought r&b was obviously having a go at prowling panther but also pointing out to redden whites that prowling panthers post was the only one that even mentioned Super Dick.

Anyway I heard that cans of 'Man Up Princess' are going cheap at Cunninghams Warehouse.

If a few of you grab some the rest of us won't need to listen to this personal attack and whining dribble

There is only one Princess at oval ave or Fortress woodville and her name is HOLDEN78
Thanks for the line Holden78

[holden78]

I was sitting not far from your right side Mickyj yesterday , what fun !

[holden78]

And to think I made the prospective coaches list Mickyj you could be my assistant and we will get CD to do the oranges and cafe lattes !

[Mickyj]

I was sitting not far from your right side Mickyj yesterday , what fun !

So did u enjoy the broken glass on the steps ?
Was that you enjoying heaps of noodles ?
Did u say hi to mighty eagles ?

[Mickyj]

And to think I made the prospective coaches list Mickyj you could be my assistant and we will get CD to do the oranges and cafe lattes !

Nah who'd be a coach there's always someone trying to knife you in the back

[Pseudo]

Seriously I really hope West beat North this week and then the Bays and that they make the 5 for a bit of success! It might make some of you lot unwind a bit!

West making the five would also require North to lose to South in the final round. I'm not saying it's impossible, but it would take some seriously creative ineptitude from the Roosters to blow that one.

[holden78]

Im a strict vegetarian , so no glass or bbq for me Im afraid ........... and no donuts either , maybe Ill have more luck next year when we have a new coach

[Mickyj]

Im a strict vegetarian , so no glass or bbq for me Im afraid ........... and no donuts either , maybe Ill have more luck next year when we have a new coach

What u didnt see all the broken glass on the steps !!did u see the bin stuffed between the seats ?
No donuts for me either .
BBQ only as subway wasn't open .
New coach new game plan new year

[drebin]

Seriously I really hope West beat North this week and then the Bays and that they make the 5 for a bit of success! It might make some of you lot unwind a bit!

West making the five would also require North to lose to South in the final round. I'm not saying it's impossible, but it would take some seriously creative ineptitude from the Roosters to blow that one.

Well we have a history of that and recently we have re-visited history.

Remember 2004 only had to beat either the Bays or South in the last 2 rounds to get the double chance. We lost to the Bays at the Bay in round 22 after leading by 4 or 5 goals half way through the game and then lost to South at home in Rd 23 after being 8 goals up in the 2nd quarter.

2005 - lost to Norwood at the Aquatic Centre in the last round to again blow the double chance.

If anyone can blow it then it's North as your best bet!

[Thiele]

West Wont make finals

[redandblack]

When I replied to Columbo's post by mentioning that the Eagles Reserves side was much more experienced than West's, I thought it was a reasonably fair statement.

As far as I can see, without knowing the Eagles players so well, the teams line up as follows:

Very experienced league players:

Eagles: Powell, Treeby, Fiacchi, all over 100 games (?), all Premiership players.

West: Birss (AFL player)

Other experienced League players:

Eagles: Fairclough, McEntee, (both with about 40 league games, Fitzgerald (not sure how many).

West: Rowe (about 25 games), Langford (VFL)

Other League experienced players:

Eagles: Staple, Rowntree, Sumner, Hill, Redden, Banner, Hicks. Any others? Some of these have only played a game or two?

West: Fisher, Webb, Silverlock, Laurie, Sukkel. Of these, Sukkel has played 1 game, Silverlock about 3 and Laurie about 5.

Of the remainder, I don't know the Eagles youngsters, who no doubt are very inexperienced, but I do know that the other 8 of West's team was made up as follows:

All Under 18's. Scott has played about 10 Reserves games, Ward about 5 and Heintze about 5. Jennings was playing his 3rd Reserves game, Keough was playing his 2nd.

Westhoff, Anderson and Ribbons were all playing their first ever Reserves game.

I'd estimate the Eagles boys would total up to about 450 league games, West's about 150 (that's a guess, but around the mark?). Seven West players have totalled about 25 Reserves games between them and 3 were making their debuts at Reserves level.

As far as the game went, the Eagles were miles too good and that was never in dispute.

Perhaps those criticising me so forcefully for what I thought was a non-controversial statement could tell me how many current Reserves teams are more experienced than the Eagles?

[MightyEagles]

I was sitting not far from your right side Mickyj yesterday , what fun !

So did u enjoy the broken glass on the steps ?
Was that you enjoying heaps of noodles ?
Did u say hi to mighty eagles ?

No they didn't. I think they were the ones right in front of me in the stand.

[MightyEagles]

Im a strict vegetarian , so no glass or bbq for me Im afraid ........... and no donuts either , maybe Ill have more luck next year when we have a new coach

What u didnt see all the broken glass on the steps !!did u see the bin stuffed between the seats ?
No donuts for me either .
BBQ only as subway wasn't open .
New coach new game plan new year

I wouldn't be surprised if he put the glass and the bin up there.
Which subway would that be? there is the one going towards town across from HJs not far from Fortress and the other next to the train line on Port Rd going the other way (westward to AAMI/Alberton).

[Mickyj]

Im a strict vegetarian , so no glass or bbq for me Im afraid ........... and no donuts either , maybe Ill have more luck next year when we have a new coach

What u didnt see all the broken glass on the steps !!did u see the bin stuffed between the seats ?
No donuts for me either .
BBQ only as subway wasn't open .
New coach new game plan new year

I wouldn't be surprised if he put the glass and the bin up there.
Which subway would that be? there is the one going towards town across from HJs not far from Fortress and the other next to the train line on Port Rd going the other way (westward to AAMI/Alberton).

Port Rd Beverley doesnt open until 8.30 am last week I was knocking on the door at 9am