Tribunal discussion/views/debate

[sjt]

Not always, we have precedent at Norwood, Garry MacIntosh.

Rowey and Fielkie (?) recently said they took a pay cut when they played for the Crows. Hence Fielkie used to flog all the Crows gear for his sports store (subsidy). But, MacIntosh may have been offered more.

You are drawing a very long bow with that comment, Garry MacIntosh played for the Norwood Football Club, full stop

The point is Rowey and Fielkie (to use two examples) didn't join the AFL for the money.

[PhilH]

Walker's one game suspension stands, Norwood failed to get the charge downgraded.

[mickey]

Wasn't the 1 game for an early plea? Seeing that he went to the tribunal, shouldn't he have got the 3 weeks?

[JK]

Wasn't the 1 game for an early plea? Seeing that he went to the tribunal, shouldn't he have got the 3 weeks?

I think they successfully argued which reduced his points, but still didn't get them down enough to be below the 1 match threshold.

[on the rails]

One game if he took early plea but 2 games if he lost the appeal was what reported in the media? Very confusing this points bullsh+t and appeals?

[Adam4]

SANFLnews SANFL
Taylor Walker found guilty of reckless conduct/low impact/high contact at Tribunal. Received 1 match ban with 23.75 carryover points. #sanfl

[Adam4]

I believe the Crows wanted to introduce AFL footage as part of their defence for Walker which the SANFL disallowed.

[Go Legs]

Serious question:
Sounds out there but:

Walker given 1 weeks suspension

Crows obviously wanted him to play on Friday Night, hence the risk of getting more weeks was taken on with the commission tribunal.

Does the 1 week suspension apply to Friday Night's Crows game therefore is free to play for Norwood on Sunday

Apparantly AFL and SANFL are reciprocal for suspension, ie; suspended from AFL cannot play for SANFL and viz versa, so 1 week served on Friday Night suspension is served???

Cheers,

[Hodges 153!]

No, he has to miss a game where the suspension is served, i.e. SANFL

Even if Norwood played Friday night, he wouldnt be eligible for the Crows Sat or Sun, has to sit out the whole weekend.

[overloaded]

Francou gets a reprimand

might make him take notice and stop writing garbage

[The Sleeping Giant]

Francou gets a reprimand

might make him take notice and stop writing garbage

So you are 1 of a very small amount that think Walker should have been suspended?

[overloaded]

Francou gets a reprimand

might make him take notice and stop writing garbage

So you are 1 of a very small amount that think Walker should have been suspended?

how do you work that out?

nostragiantdamus

[The Sleeping Giant]

I like you. Your alright.

[overloaded]

[Big Phil]

Fuller gets a reprimand for dropping the F Bomb...

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 6097804498

[The Sleeping Giant]

That's ******

[Big Phil]

That's ******

Right, that's a reprimand for you TSG

[southee]

Fuller gets a reprimand for dropping the F Bomb...

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 6097804498

Good decision.......now for Norwood. Game on!!!!

[Big Phil]

It looks like it is going to be a busy night at the SANFL tribunal tomorrow night if all players contest their charges !!!

Round 17 Reports:

Jason Sutherland (Central) Striking

Adam Grocke (Eagles) Striking

Craig Parry (Eagles) Rough Conduct

Justin Cicolella (Eagles) Charging

Aaron Fielke (West) Rough Conduct

Luke Barmby (Central) Charging

[Brucetiki]

Not surprised Barmby got reported if it was for the incident in the last quarter that started North's run of goals. Given his record, anything more than a reprimand would be excessive though.

Sutherland, I'm hoping for a reprimand but wouldn't be surprised if he gets a week.

Parry's up again, fresh off his last holiday